Hi Neighbor!

Get Personalized
Auto and Home
Insurance Quotes

Compare coverage and prices from multiple top rated Texas insurance companies.

Hippo Home Insurance
Mercury Auto and Home Insurance
Progressive Auto and Home Insurance
Safeco Auto and Home Insurance
State Auto - Auto and Home Insurance
Travelers Auto and Home Insurance

Are you feeling overwhelmed with the quoting process or coverage options?

You deserve to spend time on what you love – not quoting insurance. Whether you’re frustrated with rate increases or new to buying insurance, we’ve got you covered. We shop multiple insurance companies to make sure you’re getting a good rate now and in the future. We keep an eye on the market to make sure you’re getting the best deal. Our service is free to you and we promise not to waste your valuable time. We’re standing by to help – so give us a shot!
Insurance Quote Header

Why Neighbor's Choice?

Competitive Quotes

Competitive Texas Insurance Rates

Competitive Texas Insurance Rates

We compare multiple insurance companies so you always know you’re getting a good rate – not only now but on your renewals as well.

Insurance Agents

Access to Local Experienced Agents

Access to Local Experienced Agents

Insurance can be confusing. Don’t go at it alone. Our experienced agents help explain coverage and personalize each policy to fit your needs.
Fast Insurance Quotes

Fast, Easy Insurance Quotes

Fast, Easy Insurance Quotes

We know life can be crazy so we offer four easy ways to get started below! We work hard to complete your request the same business day and often quotes are sent within an hour or two.
Data Not Sold

We Don't Sell Your Data

We Don't Sell Your Data

Some websites collect your information to sell to multiple insurance agents. We simplify the insurance process by having one agent as your point of contact throughout the quoting and buying process.

4 easy ways to get started

telephone

Call Us

We'd love to get to know you.

laptop-phone

Start a Quote Online

No time to talk right now or maybe just looking for a price indication? Fill out a short form to get started.

upload2

Upload your current policy

We'll take a look at your current coverage and provide quotes as close as possible to what you have. It doesn't get any easier than this!

calendar-full

Schedule a Call

Pick a time that works best for you.

Protecting What Matters To You

Neighbor’s Choice Insurance has been serving the insurance needs of our neighbors in Grapevine and the state of Texas since 1991. We work with our clients to protect what matters most to them.

When you choose Neighbor’s Choice Insurance, you get insurance advice from a local experienced agent, along with the most competitive insurance rates available in your area. Our agency works with you as your insurance needs change over time and monitors your rates for as long as you’re part of our agency.

As an independent insurance agency, we search multiple insurance companies to find you the best value on your auto, home, life, boat, motorcycle and RV insurance. Insurance doesn’t have to be difficult. We work hard to make it easy.

What our clients are saying

  • 5 star review  Wendy and Jeff are great to work with. It's great when you can do business with the mom and pop place and still save money.

    thumb Mickey Aldridge
    April 21, 2021
  • 5 star review  Jeff and Wendy Caplinger have done a great job of finding the best fit for me and my auto policy. They are always caring and friendly and ready to meet my needs and that is why I have continued to be their customer for years.

    thumb Linda Sharp
    March 24, 2021
  • 5 star review  I have had my auto and homeowners insurance through Neighbor's Choice Insurance Agency, Inc. since I moved to Texas 5 years ago. They are a pleasure to work with. Always very responsive, professional and, as an independent agent, can place me with the best company for my insurance needs. Thank you, Wendy and Jeff.

    thumb Lawrence France
    June 4, 2021
  • 5 star review  Jeff was very professional and diligent in ensuring I got the coverage I needed and best suited my needs. Definitely will recommend Jeff to my family and friends.

    thumb Mark Gomez
    October 1, 2021
  • 5 star review  I have always experienced good customer service with the people working here. If ever I had an issue(which wasn't often)they have always been quick in responding to take care of the matter. I have been a customer for a good while now and I am very satisfied I picked them as my insurance company. And might I add during the pandemic Wendy made sure to reach out and let me know that if I needed anything to let them know. HOW COOL IS THAT I have never had an insurance company do that.

    thumb Tameka Dye
    May 25, 2021

We'd love to help with your insurance