Independent agency · Grapevine & DFW

Compare auto insurance from multiple companies. One local agent does the shopping.

We'll quote multiple insurance companies to help you find the right combination of coverage and price.

     EXCELLENT  
  97 reviews

Hi Neighbor! Send me your info and I’ll shop your coverage with multiple companies, then walk you through your best options. No pressure.

Jeff Caplinger

Owner & Licensed Agent

18+ years experience

Get your free auto insurance quotes

Takes about 30 seconds. We’ll do the rest.

Rather talk now? Call (817) 421-8866 or Text us

More quoting options below.

We shop these companies for you

How it works

Tell us the basics

Give your information on call, upload your current policy, or fill out an online instant quote form.

We shop multiple companies

We’ll compare coverage and price across the carriers we represent and come up with a solution that fits your needs.

Pick your option

Once you decide if you’d like to move forward with one of the quotes, the application can be signed electronically or we can set up a time to come to our local office.

What our clients are saying

4.9 97 reviews

Claire Lawry ★★★★★ 2 months ago
We've renewed our Homeowner and Car insurance policies thru Jeff Caplinger with Neighbors Choice for the past 5 years, and we've been extremely satisfied with the level of customer service he's provided. He has made the yearly … More policy renewals a smooth and stress free process which we sincerely appreciate.
Mel Roggenbuck ★★★★★ 6 months ago
I was looking for auto insurance with a reasonable premium. Jeff found a real good deal on my coverage. It saved me $1,000 a year on my coverage.
Mel
Michael Fontes ★★★★★ 9 months ago
I've gotten a motorcycle policy and an auto policy from them on two different occasions. So much easier than dealing with online quotes and far cheaper too. Not sure why, but every insurance company's online quote was more than … More double the rate I got from Neighbor's Choice. Highly recommended.
Garry A ★★★★★ 11 months ago
Excellent communication and friendly service. We transferred from another Agency and could not be happier. Jeff communicated based on my preference - which was email and online. Not a single hitch in the process.
Sadruddin Panjwani ★★★★★ a year ago
Quick and efficient no pressure sales.
Helpful, knowledgeable and courteous.
Thank you Jeff for helping me with my auto insurance.

Why Choose Neighbor's Choice?

Independent

We work with multiple insurance companies to find the right coverage and value for your needs.

Local

Based in Grapevine, Texas on Northwest Hwy. We know Texas roads and Texas weather.

Personal

You'll work with an actual agent who answers your questions and is here when you need us.

Easiest Quoting Option

Upload your policy

Send us your current declarations page. We'll start by matching your coverage and quote it apples to apples.