Independent agency · Grapevine & DFW
Compare car insurance from multiple companies. One local agent does the shopping.
We'll quote multiple insurance companies to help you find the right combination of coverage and price.
- We quote 10+ car insurance companies, not just one
- No pressure, no obligation. Keep your current policy if it's the better deal
- Work directly with a licensed Texas agent
Hi Neighbor! Send me your info and I’ll shop your coverage with multiple companies, then walk you through your best options. No pressure.
Jeff Caplinger
Owner & Licensed Agent
18+ years experience
Get your free car insurance quotes
Takes about 30 seconds. We’ll do the rest.
Rather talk now? Call (817) 421-8866 or Text us
More quoting options below.
We shop these companies for you
How it works
1
Tell us the basics
Give your information on call, upload your current policy, or fill out an online instant quote form.
2
We shop multiple companies
We’ll compare coverage and price across the carriers we represent and come up with a solution that fits your needs.
3
Pick your option
Once you decide if you’d like to move forward with one of the quotes, the application can be signed electronically or we can set up a time to come to our local office.
What our clients are saying
Why Choose Neighbor's Choice?
Independent
We work with multiple insurance companies to find the right coverage and value for your needs.
Local
Based in Grapevine, Texas on Northwest Hwy. We know Texas roads and Texas weather.
Personal
You'll work with an actual agent who answers your questions and is here when you need us.
Easiest Quoting Option
Upload your policy
Send us your current declarations page. We'll start by matching your coverage and quote it apples to apples.
Prefer to quote yourself?
Frequently asked questions
Where is your service available?
Our office is in Grapevine, Texas, but we serve clients anywhere in Texas. Most of our work is done by phone, email, or text, so you’ll get the same personal service whether you live down the street or across the state.
What is an independent insurance agency?
An independent insurance agency works with multiple insurance companies instead of just one. Because we’re independent, we can shop your coverage with several top-rated carriers, including Progressive, Travelers, and Liberty Mutual. Our job is to find the right coverage at the best price for you.
If your rates go up at renewal or you have a life change, like buying a new home or adding a teen driver, we can shop your policy again without you having to start over with a new agent.
Is there a fee for quotes or your service?
We never charge for quotes. We don’t do pressure sales and there’s no obligation to purchase.
For most auto policies, there’s no fee. We’re paid a commission by the insurance company you choose. The only exception is a minimum liability policy that isn’t set up on auto pay or paid in full. In that case, a one-time $75 application fee applies when your policy is issued. You can avoid it by choosing auto pay or paying your premium in full, and we’ll always go over any fee with you before you buy.
Why buy through an agency instead of directly from GEICO or Progressive?
When you go directly to an insurance company, you only see that company’s price, so getting several quotes means filling out form after form. We quote multiple top-rated companies for you, including some of the same names you’d find online, and can show you your options side by side.
You also get a local agent who knows you, instead of a different person every time you call a 1-800 number. And our service doesn’t stop once you buy. We’re here to help with policy changes, claims, and shopping your rates again at renewal.